As of update 1.2.0 cooking broth no longer makes your pot dirty!

A compat request for Salt and Sands; could you add a recipe for turning 2 cooked freshwater mussels into 1 liter of fish broth, and another for turning 1 cooked clam or scallop into 1 liter of fish broth?

SpacemanSpliff Yeah the cooking pot thing is a vanilla thing, it does that with all items that outputs into something that's not a meal so it'll do this with candles and pitch glue too. Also there's no spoilage timer when the broth is still hot lol (trust me it'll turn into rot eventually, I rotted most of my stock that I made during winter lol)

Really happy that I can put bones to use for foods. Few things Ive noticed.

Bone broth doesnt have any spoilage timer as far as I can tell. Im not sure if you intend for it to or not, but broths definitely can go bad (ask me how I know lol).

EDIT: nevermind, I now see a spoiler timer on my barrel of bone broth.

Also, when cooking bone broths, the cooking pot will play the cooking animation until the broth is removed from the pot, not when it is ready. 

Ive only made bone broth so far so Im not sure if the other items in this mod behave similarly. Either way, love the mod so far. Thank you.

KibbyTom its meant to be used as stock for soups, not drinked directly.

It's working and I made some bone broth but it gives an order of magnitude less hydration than water and no protein satiation, do i have to configure the values?

Tahvohck Go on the official VS discord and find my mod thread, we can discuss it there it'll be easier

I'm looking into making a patch, since unfortunately I like a lot of the stuff that LTF adds beyond just the pemmican (the big ones are algae, rusks, and mushrooms). It's going mostly well, but one thing I noticed is that LTF uses things like shapeElement: "bowl/vegetable 1/*" while the vanilla game uses shapeElement: "bowl/vegetable base 1/*"shapeElement: "bowl/vegetable base 1/*"

I tried looking into what shape element does, but I can't find any reference to that in the shape files, any documentation, or any bits in the game code that seem to use it - but it almost certainly has to do with the translation strings that LTF has broken. I don't want to fix this mod just to break LTF's ingredients, can you point me in the right direction?

Nico_Nico_Nyx Ah thank you, I hadn't read the incompat well enough.

Tahvohck You have Long Term Food which is listed in the incompatibility section, it breaks the translation because the mod author there overwrites the entire soup recipe instead of patching into it. If you're using it for the pemmican, fret not as that's the next mod I'm working on :D

I'm not having issues with Expanded Matter, but the broth is pulling the wrong translation (?) when cooked into a soup.

Hello Nico_Nico_Nyx, I have translated the mod into Spanish-Spain 'es-es.json' for include in future versions.

RiverTheSheep On the official VS Discord I have a thread for my mod there, you can send me your list there and we can try to figure out the culprit

Hmmm, I'll keep trying to figure it out, I appreciate you trying to help out. Is there an easy way to share my entire mod list? 

RiverTheSheep OthalaTorkhan I have no idea what is wrong with both your modlists, but I have tested my mod + Expanded Matter's latest release 3.3.0 and it works perfectly fine with both bones and bonemeal. The problem is not my mod, another one in your list is interfering with it, you'll need to figure it out because I do not know your modlists, I play with this in a 100+ modlist and have no issue at all. And I also checked EM's recipes and none of them are the exact same as mine, furthermore none of them uses the cooking pot as far as I know. I'm sorry but this is as much as I can help right now.

Are you accepting translations? I got a pt-br one right here! (this is way more lightweight than expanded foods, but still gives an use to leftover bones, so I'm gonna give it a go)

Nico_Nico_Nyx I am having the very same issue when it comes to using bonemeal itself, I just tested this using bones, bonemeal AND small bones. Small bones are the only one that continued to cook AND had a progress bar for cooking properly. It seems that Expanded Matter has a recipe for both bones and bonemeal for its own items.

I got lucky and found a huge lake so I set up a house right on the edge of it, I can get roughly 30 fish in the span of like 8mins. One downside to it is there is a spot where I keep getting jumped by black bears, but the water makes it easy to swim backwards while using a spear to poke the bears.

Bonemeal doesn't work either, I haven't tried tiny bones yet but I'll try it when I get some 

Tiny bones do work, but i think because bones have a cook temp of 1000C for their EM recipe they just don't ever get hot enough for it to allow it to make anything, maybe?

RiverTheSheep I'll try to test on my end with EM as well since I have it on my main save, if you press H on the bone and see if it appears in any cooking pot recipe from Expanded Matter it would help a lot. But for bone broth you can also make it with bonemeal or tiny bones if the incompatiblity persists.

Nope, it still cooks forever. Is it possibly an incompatibility with expanded matter? Since that lets you cook bones into ash. The other broths seem to work completely fine so it's something wrong with bones specifically.

I'll let you know when I play later today 

RiverTheSheep Update to the latest version and tell me if your bug persists. No more dirty cooking pot shenanigans

HOTFIX 1.1.1: Fixed the accidental soup when making vegetable broth inside a clean pot. The recipe now requires one bone on top of the vegetables.

Jayro in all my testing I completely forgot to test it from a clean pot lol I'll fix this standby for update lol. In the meantime, for veggie broth use an already dirty pot.

RiverTheSheep do you have other mods, or does this only happen when this mod is on its own?

Hi, I think this might be a bug because when I try to make the Vegetable Broth recipe it turns straight into soup hehe.

I was using a clean pot, though? I put 6L water and 6 and 6 bones and it says it'll make bone broth, but the arrow never starts filling up

RiverTheSheep Once you make bone broth your pot will become dirty and can't be used for cooking hence the seemingly infinite cooking, you need to transfer the broth to a clean pot in order to cook. It's a game limitation unfortunately.

I might be doing something wrong but it seems to infinitely try to cook but never does?

Echoweaver I haven't looked into the hooks for vanilla naming schemes more than I needed to, but I know that to fix the names showing up properly on meals and recipe I had to add my lang file inside a /game/lang folder so that the game would properly read it. I think it was like meal-ingredient-secondary-soup-

I love the idea of bone broth. Another logical and useful thing to do with bones! And thanks for linking to my mod 😉. Pizza2004 commented on Variations on a Meal to say that there are hooks in the vanilla naming scheme for adding broth in the future. I don't know if you knew and/or made use of that. Meal naming is SO COMPLICATED but cool.

This is really cool! The game can absolutely do with more multi step cooking recipes.