Bronze_Granum thank you for looking into it, my groups butcher/hunter was in panic mode with the build up of blood.

Kalina Found out the issue was accidentally caused by cannibalism overwriting the default blood recipes. This is now fixed in the new update.

THELlON The newest update should now address this issue! I was able to get it working on other systems, too, so it should be good to go! Please let me know if the problem somehow persists!

Kalina I forgot about this issue, but this is something I need to bring up with CaptainOats again (he has been rather sick), but essentially Butchering just needs to swap their own patch from being add to addmerge, and I think that'll fix it. I'll talk to CaptainOats about it

Just a heads up but it seems with the addition of Sapient Blood the normal blood from Butchering is no longer usable in soups, only Sapient blood is. It was fine prior to the update so I am just running on the assumption that the addition changed somethign to make the butchering blood non-usable in that manner.

THELlON Thank you for letting me know! I've been able to replicate the issue now, but it is proving incredibly difficult to fix. Essentially, it works fine on my computer, but when testing it on another device, it is seemingly unable to find the tags in the registry, even when they should exist. I'm still fighting with it. If you want to still have corpses in the meantime, I think turning off raceuniquecorpses should give you seraph corpses every time from players now.

Bronze_Granum Unable to tag me was probably because THELlON uses a lowercase L in place of the i, lol. Any how I tried 1.2.1 and still had the same issue of everything in the mod working aside players not dropping carcasses, HOWEVER I tried version 1.1.1 and was able to get my corpse to produce a carcass! I did this with and without the player corpse mod and I was able to produce a carcass each time and was able to interact with it as intended. So there's a diffrence between the two versions just breaking that part of the mod, at least it's breaking for me idk about other players. Hope this helps in some way.

AgentOfChaos As of update 1.2.1, traders and villagers can be permanently killed. Just turn off the respawning trader and respawning villager settings. It is very much not recommended to turn off villager respawning, though, as those are important to the story at times, I think

@THELION (Not sure why it wont let me tag you),

I have fixed this bug as of 1.2.1! It was caused by a mistake where if the game could not find the undead or skeleton tags (from the skeleton mod), it would automatically assume the players were skeletons and instantly rot all corpses. That is obviously not the intention, so I fixed that. Please let me know if you have any more bugs!

ausdog It should be fine to add this to an existing world. It doesn't use any world generation or anything like that, and the scripts are attached to base game events, so it shouldn't cause issues

@THELION Could you send your modlist and logs? I've heard from another on the discord that they've had a similar issue. So far I've been unable to replicate the bug, so any info helps!

Just downloaded 1.2.0 and threw the zip into my server's mod folder and everything seems to be working just fine aside of players not dropping carcasses? I have several other mods installed including Player Corpses so I tried an offline single player world with just Cannibalism to see if it was conflicting with another mod but despite dying to creatures or killing myself through commands, I never drop a carcass. I spawned some villagers and killed them and I can harvest them just fine it's just players that don't drop carcasses, also PVP only corpses is set to false. Is there something in the files I need to change or am I misunderstanding something about the mod? Thanks.

Bronze_Granum NDL Villagers is a mod that let's you make your own town with villagers. There is another village mod called VS Village that does something similar that'd also be cool to see compat. with if it doesn't already work. Also, is it fine to add this mod to an existing world?

Coda_Vanistok As of 1.1.1, players could limit corpse spawning to PVP and could control the satiety and healing of pale meat. As of the new 1.2.0 update, you can now toggle in the config "human pale meat" which makes villagers and traders produce palemeat.

sloppysteev What is NDL? I've not heard of it before. If they use the base classes and entity types from the base game, it'll work, but if they are new entity types, no, it wont work

Does this work with NDL Villagers?  if not, have you considered it?  i know it works with what's present in the game already, but it would kinda neat to be able to build a human farm.

Loiremar What do you mean, ExpandedFoodsPatch_1.7.6-pre.107, is that an unofficial update? 1.1.0 works with Expanded Foods Stable, and 1.1.1 works with expanded foods dev update. I am also going to update it shortly with the butchering fix, too. It's just been taking longer than planned because I have been adding new features and things as well.

It's not working with expandedfoodspatch_1.7.6-pre.107 :(

Crashing on the handbook entry upon any recipe that includes palemeat

I did a gutted version to be able to use it before official would come out: https://news.kalataka.ru/show/mod/34917

ScarlettJFG Thanks for letting me know! The bug was caused by me accidentally having the rot recipe for butchering compatibility under my general recipes instead of relying on butchering. So while it doesn't cause a crash for me, it makes sense that it cannot find any rotten bodies when no body items are made without butchering. I've fixed this and will be releasing a new update shortly (along with some new features)

Bronze_Granum
Searching for "Rot" in the handbook and clicking on the entry causes an instant crash, with the game crash saying it couldn't resolve the recipe ingredient wildcard "cannibalism:*-rotten".

Specific crash:

Checked with just Cannibalism loaded as well and the same error occurs.

Loaded Mods: game@1.21.5, cannibalism@1.1.1, creative@1.21.5, survival@1.21.5
System.ArgumentException: Attempted to resolve the recipe ingredient wildcard Item cannibalism:*-rotten but there are no such items/blocks!

Mod version 1.1.1

Edit: Deleting the file "rot.json" in '~assets/cannibalism/recipes/grid' Worked for me in a singleplayer world. Not sure if this affects anything else but I had no issues from at least checking the handbook then.

AgentOfChaos

Because I'm blind and didn't actually ping the mod creator: Bronze_Granum

Terribly sorry AgentOfChaos, I think it was the proximity to the other conversations that lead me to ping the wrong person.

Edit: Oh- It's because I was reading your comment when making a statement about config options.

@Coda_Vanistok why tag me? I'm not apart of any of that.

AgentOfChaos

When you do get around to a config, adding an option to limit the body creation to player on player deaths would be very appreciated. As it is, the amount of bodies we have on our server from the mod has turned a niche scare feature with little to gain into an atrocity for our local blacksmith, who would much rather have the satisfaction of collecting their bodies fresh inbetween "working hours" than simply have the novelty taken away by people tossing them their bodies post death.

Also, a config to make all "human" meat pale meat, and to make it's nutrition more punishing, maybe even drunkeness enducing, would be very appreciated.

osayra Bronze_Granum

There is the bodyfat mod, perhaps a little feature can use the player's body fat level to determine extra fat or meat (Specifically the loss of fat upon death so as to not allow you to repeatedly murder allies).

osayra I've actually been wanting to do that. Biggest hitch would be because it requires overriding the game's default system. I'm sure it's possible though, and I've somewhat been wanting to do that anyway.

AgentOfChaos I'll see about doing that for the next update, then! Always happy to hear suggestions

I think that would help to add as a config option. i know i would really appreciate it. so would others i bet.

If this is doable , would be interesting if meat drops are tied to the player nutrition stat, like the more they've eaten over time the more meat they drop. This could let you fatten them up..  

I had another suggestion where if a player dies from hunger/starvation specifically, they won't drop meat. I think it could sort of help the player self-harvesting issue, but there's still fall damage, etc so it might be too much trouble for nothing.

AgentOfChaos I considered adding that as a config option, actually. It's much easier to do and is essentially the result of before I wrote custom code to make them respawn. The problem with that, though, is that I saw that as potentially causing huge issues with the game's flow (I.E. player kills the starting treasure hunter), or issues with how on a server you might want to go and shop with a trader, only to discover that your friend ate him and now you can never trade there again.

If people want that as a config option, then I can probably do that at some point.

traders can be consumed now??? funiture trader here i come! somthing nifty would be a mechanic that makes it so if you kill them and harvest them, they will not respawn.

Bronze_Granum I love you!!!!!!! They shall be consumed in the finest of soups!

aWhatsit Zuul blueblynd The new update is out, and you can now eat traders and villagers as well!

aWhatsit Glad to hear it! The update probably wont be too long now, as the only things I have left to do is make sure that collecting bodies with butchering still allows traders and villagers to respawn, and I've been fussing with the villagers to make sure they don't break entirely when you harvest them.

Can't wait to see your update, have been keeping up with your stuff in the Butchering discord thread. Great stuff!

Great mod, but I would like to see an update about NPC someday.
Good luck. 💜

blueblynd I've been considering adding support for that actually, as multiple people have mentioned wanting to hunt the NPCs. I've never tried to kill them when I've played so I often assumed you couldn't. If I can find the time for it, I would love to add NPCs, and they in theory, shouldn't take too long to add. Hard to say entirely, though

If you ever had the time, I'd love to see this mod add support for NPCs like traders and (vanilla) villagers; I love the roleplay potential of this but never have the time to play multiplayer, so it would be a fun middle ground for singleplayer!

(...Maybe configurable, though, since I can imagine how such a feature would be abused on multiplayer servers)

Oh boy! Time for derangement and degeneracy :D

Ah, finally, I can play rimworld in vintage story.

Yay! Welcome to Flavor Town! 

*Kriegsman Inttensifies*

Mmmm. Yum.

gonna feed my dinosaurs with my friends' corpses

Can finally perform blood libel!

Best mod.
Finally I can honor jesus and eat his flesh!

Bronze_Granum Which I respect to not make it too easy which why I didn't like the limitation and the raw meat you can eat unlike other types of meat.
The mod can also have some good potencial to have colored leather from seraphs bcs of the skin color choices that can be used in a lot of clothing and armor which can be cool in theory but we'll see in the future.
Mummification can be fallen into that as it was a a practise to preserve corpses which old times some people used them for medicine, vandalism and canibalism and more but it can be a seperate mod if you want to expand the concept.
There's a lot of references you can take with canibalism as it's a great way to explore the types of it without being punished.
I can't wait where it goes that can explore such topics.

Ruyeex Yeah, I read up about that while I was working on the mod. Honestly extremely interesting and I'm glad you mentioned it. That said, I chose to keep the health problems from it purely for balance reasons. I.E. Supposedly a human male body could feed 25 people for a little over two days. Now, if players can just die and eat their old corpse, that essentially makes food endless.

Personally,  I slightly headcanon that since it is technically Seraph meat, and we don't know how edible Seraph meat is, it might be slightly toxic (however unlikely). If I added humans that were edible, I'd probably use red meat, since you don't have infinite access to them and then it rewards the hunt a bit.

The meat is not bad or even harmful in real life unless you eat the brains and the liver.
The meat tastes similarly to chicken or even with pork and beef.
VSauce, Wiki and infographics has some information about it if you want to check out but I doubt as it's already giving too much pressure of making the mod looking to encourage it.

YES. Just YESSSSS!!!!

wonderful!